US Dime Struck on Nail Realizes $42,300

by CoinNews.net on January 8, 2016 · 9 comments

An undated Roosevelt dime struck on a 6-penny nail realized $42,300 in Heritage’s Florida United Numismatists U.S. Coins Signature® Auction in Tampa.

Images of a Roosevelt Dime Struck on a Nail

Images of Roosevelt dime struck on a nail

The error, graded MS65 PCGS, had a pre-auction estimate of $10,000+. It was purchased by a prominent American collector of many kinds of collectibles across a wide range of categories, according to Heritage.

"Significant error coins are among the most sought-after in the hobby," said Greg Rohan, President of Heritage Auctions, "as evidenced by the spirited bidding among collectors over this coin."

What is known is that the zinc-coated nail found its way into the coinage production line during the minting of Roosevelt dimes and apparently escaped through normal distribution channels.

"This is certainly among the most unique and mysterious errors to ever come to auction," Rohan said. "The truth is, no one really knows how or why it was struck."

This error coin is not the first coin to have such a distinction. A few examples of cents struck on nails were discovered in the 1970s, notes Heritage. The total number of similar errors is thought to be around six.

Heritage Auctions is the largest auction house founded in the U.S. and the world’s third largest, with annual sales of about $900 million and over 950,000 online bidder members. To learn more about the company, visit HA.com.

9
Leave a Reply

avatar
  
smilegrinwinkmrgreenneutraltwistedarrowshockunamusedcooleviloopsrazzrollcryeeklolmadsadexclamationquestionideahmmbegwhewchucklesillyenvyshutmouth
9 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
7 Comment authors
Tom D in SCfenderbender86RonnieBGoodjimRichard Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
Notify of
Seth Riesling
Guest
Seth Riesling

Mike Unser – You really “hit the nail on the head” with this article! (Sorry, I couldn’t hold back the bad pun). I used to get Heritage coin auction catalogs back when I was a customer in the 80s when they only sold stamps & coins. Now they sell every category, including a T-Rex fossilized skeleton that was seized by U.S. government officials after the auction because it was illegally imported into the U.S. from Mongolia. Heritage would auction off human organs if they could! Lol. These errors on nails didn’t make it out of the Mint legally, they were taken out by employees in shoes in the 1970s when the metal detector machines didn’t detect all the way to the sole of your shoes. Also, some error coins escaped when the Mint used to send out forklifts for repair & oil changes & were found in the oil input… Read more »

Boz
Guest
Boz

That should be a true statement, yet the gold coins purloined in 1913 by a San Francisco mint employee, buried in a coffee can, and “discovered” by an alleged bird watcher last year were deemed finders keepers.

Seth Riesling
Guest
Seth Riesling

Boz –

You are probably partially right on your comments. The Mint lawyers are basically acting as if they are impotent on such matters & spend most of their time worried about U.S. Mint trademark issues instead! I called them once about an illegal offering of a U.S. Mint Martha Washington bronze test strike experimental piece going to auction & even contacted the U.S. Secret Service about it and the agent called me back & said unfortunately the Mint lawyers basically didn’t care since it wasn’t a legal tender coin! That piece sold at auction a month later for $52,000 ! But when a 1933 $20 gold coin came on the market for $millions, the Mint’s lawyers stood up at attention & fought a 4-year long court battle for it! Go figure. Very inconsistent they are at the US MInt on this matter.

-NumisDudeTX

Richard
Guest
Richard

The addition 1933 double eagles apparently can’t be sold under the agreement with Fenton when his one Farouk specimen was monetized. As for the others, I think at this point the Mint would look pretty crazy going after a famous 103 year coin, even if they have the legal right (also, its issuance was pretty murky and the illegality could be argued in court). Maybe it comes down to ego–what coins they have gone after (such as pre-Fenton ’33s) they have to keep going after just because they already are and can’t admit a mistake. But the rest would be a major hassle.

Seth Riesling
Guest
Seth Riesling

Richard – You are right on point on the King Farouk/Stephen Fenton specimen of the 1933 $20 Saint-Gaudens coin being the only coin of its type that is currently officially monetized by U.S. Mint officials. But those coins were struck in large amounts in 1933 for circulation but were ordered to be melted by President FDR’s orders etc. But the five 1913 Liberty Head “nickels” were never approved by Congress or U.S. Mint officials & were struck by at least 2 Philadelphia Mint employees (one in the die department & one press operator at least, & obviously after hours since it was not approved on any level !) The fact that they only struck five specimens (that we know of since 1913) also suggests that it was a quick “after midnight” type illegal operation. Otherwise they would have struck more to make more $ selling them to the dealer who… Read more »

jim
Guest
jim

Not error coins in my opinion. That implies the mint intended to do this and I doubt that. The offender should loose his job for putting a nail in the press.

RonnieBGood
Guest
RonnieBGood

I agree that this and several other “error” mintages were (proven) the result of an “Inside Job” by a US Mint employee(s). The reasons are made obvious by the Auction results.

fenderbender86
Guest
fenderbender86

Whats next, a quarter struck on a stuffed teddy bear? I’m surprised they didn’t slap a green bean on it as well.

Tom D in SC
Guest
Tom D in SC

MS 65?!? Really?! What’s the deal about grading a nail but PCGS won’t grade a coin because it was cleaned or has a scratch on it or some other “defect” that renders a coin ungradeable? Yet they jump all over a nail that I doubt was an accidental. A NAIL!! I just read an article where PCGS was rated as having the highest standards. What kind of standards do they have? It isn’t an error coin–it’s not even a coin and certainly it wasn’t done in error, I believe it to be intentional. How is a nail going to run through the system and come out pristine with an MS65 dime stamped on it? And ….”no one really knows how or why it was struck”? I think $42,300 explains that statement. If the nail wasn’t graded, I’m thinking it wouldn’t have been more than a curious little trinket.