Millions Lost From Counterfeit Coins, Hobby Leaders Warn

by on October 12, 2009 · 3 comments

(Fallbrook, California) – Chinese-made counterfeit coins pose a significant financial threat to unsuspecting consumers, according to leaders of five of the country’s most influential rare coin organizations. They warn the public is spending millions of dollars on fake U.S. coins offered in online auctions and elsewhere, such as flea markets and swap meets.

Counterfeit 1916-D dime
This counterfeit 1916-D Winged Liberty Head dime was sold online. Photo credit: Numismatic Guaranty Corporation.

In a jointly-issued consumer advisory (below) the groups caution the public not to purchase any so-called "replica" coins because they may be in violation of federal law. They also urge consumers to only purchase genuine rare coins from reputable, professional dealers or face the risk of losing money on copies that are illegal to re-sell.

Below is the consumer protection warning issued by (in alphabetical order) the American Numismatic Association (, the Industry Council for Tangible Assets (, Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (, Professional Coin Grading Service ( and the Professional Numismatists Guild (

Consumer Advisory About Counterfeit Coins

Jointly issued by

American Numismatic Association (

Industry Council for Tangible Assets (

Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (

Professional Coin Grading Service (

Professional Numismatists Guild (

Hobby periodicals report that more than a million counterfeit coins manufactured in China have been fraudulently sold in the United States posing a significant financial risk for unsuspecting consumers. Buyer beware! Consumers who buy an item based only on its perceived rarity and who have no knowledge as to how to determine whether the coin is genuine subject themselves to great risk of losing their money

The American Numismatic Association (ANA), the Industry Council for Tangible Assets (ICTA), Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC), Professional Coin Grading Service ( and the Professional Numismatists Guild (PNG) urge consumers to educate themselves before making purchases: know what you are buying and purchase only from reputable, experienced rare coin dealers (professional numismatists).


"We believe many of these counterfeits subsequently are being resold as genuine rare coins in online auctions and at flea markets and swap meets," said Clifford Mishler, ANA President.

"Millions of dollars already have been spent on these fakes and potentially millions more may be unwittingly lost by consumers who mistakenly think they’re getting a genuine rare coin," warned Paul Montgomery, PNG President.


It is a violation of United States federal law to sell unmarked replicas. The U.S. Hobby Protection Act, first enacted in 1973 (Public Law 93-167 15 US Code 2101 et seq) requires manufacturers and importers of imitation numismatic items to mark them plainly and permanently with the word, "COPY" in accordance with the Code of Federal Regulations (16 CFR part 304).

Fake 1915-D Half Eagle
No 1915-dated Half Eagles were struck at the Denver Mint. This counterfeit “1915-D” was sold online. Photo credit: Numismatic Guaranty Corporation.

Thousands of coins described as "copy" or "replica" are listed for sale in online auctions every day. There also are numerous reports of replica coins being exported from China without the word, "COPY," incused in the surface as the law requires. On most on-line offers, photos of the replica depict the word, falsely showing consumers a different product than the one they’re actually buying.


"We believe many of these are simply counterfeits that eventually will be purchased for significant amounts of money by unsuspecting buyers," said Fred Weinberg, ICTA Chairman.


Coin World, a respected weekly hobby publication, recently reported that 99 percent of the "replica" items sold into the U.S. market do not contain the required "COPY" markings. One counterfeiter in China told the publication he already has produced and sold more than one million coins.

To protect the public, our organizations are aggressively working to

    • combat the unrestricted imports of counterfeit coins;
    • halt the fraudulent offerings in online auctions;
    • explore asking for legal actions by federal law enforcement agencies against importers and re-sellers of illegal numismatic items;
    • explore united legal action by our organizations to protect the public.


"Even during the recession, the United States rare coin market remains vibrant and active with an estimated $5 billion in annual sales. We urge collectors and investors to become knowledgeable and use common sense when buying," said Steven R. Eichenbaum, NGC Chief Executive Officer.

"Some of the counterfeits are of extremely high quality, so if you don’t know rare coins, you’d better know your coin dealer. You should only buy from reputable and knowledgeable dealers who have a return policy with regard to non-genuine coins," said Don Willis, President of the Professional Coin Grading Service.


In addition, there are reliable rare coin authentication companies whose certified coins are guaranteed for authenticity. Two such companies, among others, are Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) and Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS).

For a copy of the informative booklet, What You Should Know Before You Buy Rare Coins, send $1 to the Professional Numismatists Guild, 3950 Concordia Lane, Fallbrook, CA 92028.

# # #

{ 3 comments… read them below or add one }

Richard Perarson October 13, 2009 at 12:12 pm

I believe the Treasury Dept should check ebay, (among others) for this practice. They have been warned repeatedly about some of the sellers, selling counterfeit, or “replica coins. they seem to think it is okay. I for one will not but any coin that is not genuine, and tested to be the genuine article. If I can’t test tyhe coin, there will be no deal.
The United States should get very aggressive in the halting of the importing of these counterfeit coins, by imposing heavy fines dor the first incident, and shutting down the business, on the second incident.
Ebay should police itself for this ongoing practice, but (boesn’t)

Jim Lasley January 23, 2010 at 11:30 pm

Richard- All I can say is that I agree with you 100% I was a big E-Bay buyer last year and into this year and as of a month ago I will no longer purchase my coins on e-bay.

I now buy from a local coin dealer in Northern Ohio!

Jim Lasley

Jason Fisher January 26, 2010 at 4:32 am

I am ok with these fake coins but do understand how they are being sold off as originals. I am a younger collector for about 10 years. I only collect and only by from sites that I could visit in person but would only buy from Ebay or others only with a graded capsule from one of the grading companies. The only coins I have are certified so I or others know what they are. I would like to see that any coin of value of 100 to be certified and cross my fingers that these fake coins never pass certification as originals or you can kiss it all away.

Jason Fisher , Barcelona Spain

Leave a Comment