Penny Costs 2.1 Cents to Make in 2021, Nickel Costs 8.52 Cents; US Mint Realizes $381.2M in Seigniorage

40
Lincoln cents - reverses shown
Last year, the U.S. Mint spent 2.1 cents to make and distribute each Lincoln cent. The Mint’s cost for each Jefferson nickel was 8.52 cents.

The price for manufacturing U.S. coins for circulation went up last year, except for the half dollar, the United States Mint disclosed this month in its 2021 Annual Report. And for a sixteenth straight year, the unit cost for both cents and nickels was above their face values.

The Mint struck nearly 15 billion coins for circulation during the fiscal year.

"Despite operating under continued restrictions due to COVID-19, the Mint shipped 14.7 billion circulating coins during FY 2021. This increased level of circulating coin production was necessary to meet increased coin orders from the Federal Reserve," the U.S. Mint’s annual report said

In FY 2021, the toll to make, administer and distribute the 1-cent coin climbed to 2.1 cents from 1.76 cents while the cost for the 5-cent coin increased to 8.52 cents from 7.42 cents. Higher prices for copper and zinc accounted for much of the increases.

"Compared to last year, FY 2021 average spot prices for nickel increased 28.1 percent to $17,503.10 per tonne, average copper prices also increased 48.2 percent to $8,676.77 per tonne, and average zinc prices increased 27.9 percent to $2,821.12 per tonne," the U.S. Mint noted.

Lincoln cents have a composition of 2.5% copper with the balance zinc. Five-cent coins are minted in 25% nickel with the balance copper. Dimes, quarters, and half dollars are each composed in 8.33% nickel with their balance copper.

Cost to Make Dimes, Quarters and Half Dollars

Unlike for cents and nickels, the U.S. Mint made money in striking dimes, quarters, and half dollars because the cost of manufacturing and distributing them was lower than their face values.

In FY2021, the unit cost for the quarter increased to 9.63 cents from 8.62 cents and the dime’s unit cost rose to 4.39 cents from 3.73 cents. The unit cost for the half dollar, meanwhile, decreased to 11.67 cents from 25 cents — supported by an increase in the number of half dollars made and shipped to Federal Reserve Banks.

The following two tables summarize U.S. Mint costs for the cent through half dollar in fiscal years 2020 and 2021.

FY 2021 Unit Cost to Produce and Distribute 1c, 5c, 10c, 25c, and 50c Coins

One-Cent Five-Cent Dime Quarter Half Dollar
Cost of Goods Sold ($) 0.0181 0.0744 0.0386 0.0843 0.0917
Sales, General & Administrative ($) 0.0026 0.0095 0.0047 0.0106 0.0167
Distribution to Reserve Banks ($) 0.0003 0.0013 0.0006 0.0014 0.0083
Total Unit Cost ($) 0.0210 0.0852 0.0439 0.0963 0.1167

 

FY 2020 Unit Cost to Produce and Distribute 1c, 5c, 10c, 25c, and 50c Coins

One-Cent Five-Cent Dime Quarter Half Dollar
Cost of Goods Sold ($) 0.0151 0.0653 0.0326 0.0760 0.2500
Sales, General & Administrative ($) 0.0022 0.0080 0.0042 0.0091
Distribution to Reserve Banks ($) 0.0003 0.0009 0.0005 0.0011
Total Unit Cost ($) 0.0176 0.0742 0.0373 0.0862 0.2500

 

In profit from seigniorage — the difference between the face value and cost of producing and distributing circulating coins, the dime in FY 2021 realized $172 million while the quarter brought $349.3 million. (The U.S. Mint transfers seigniorage to the Treasury General Fund to help finance national debt.) Relatively few half dollars were produced for circulation compared to other denominations, but the U.S. Mint still earned $4.6 million for them.

In contrast, the cent and nickel have lost money since 2006.

Unit Costs and Seigniorage for Cent and Nickel from 2005 to 2021

Fiscal Year Lincoln Cent Unit Cost Jefferson Nickel Unit Cost Combined 1c and 5c Seigniorage (in millions)
2005 0.0097 0.0484 $4.40
2006 0.0121 0.0597 ($32.90)
2007 0.0167 0.0953 ($98.60)
2008 0.0142 0.0883 ($47.00)
2009 0.0162 0.0603 ($22.00)
2010 0.0179 0.0922 ($42.60)
2011 0.0241 0.1118 ($116.70)
2012 0.0200 0.1009 ($109.20)
2013 0.0183 0.0941 ($104.50)
2014 0.0166 0.0809 ($90.50)
2015 0.0143 0.0744 ($74.40)
2016 0.0150 0.0632 ($66.80)
2017 0.0182 0.0660 ($89.80)
2018 0.0206 0.0753 ($119.00)
2019 0.0199 0.0762 ($102.90)
2020 0.0176 0.0742 ($101.00)
2021 0.0210 0.0852 ($144.60)

 

The U.S. Mint produces and issues circulating coins to Federal Reserve Banks in quantities to support their service to commercial banks and other financial institutions. FY 2021 compared to the prior year saw both production increases and decreases among denominations. In summary, the Mint delivered a total of:

  • 7.613 billion cents, down 6.8% from the previous year;
  • 1.736 billion nickels, up 8.6% from the previous year;
  • 3.066 billion dimes, up 9.5% from the previous year;
  • 2.274 billion quarters, down 21.8% from the previous year; and
  • 12 million half dollars compared to no shipments in the previous year.

The five denominations combined to 14.701 billion coins, registering a 5% decrease from the 15.479 billion coins delivered in FY 2020.

The Fed pays face value for each coin they receive and, as such, the U.S. Mint’s FY 2021 circulating revenue for coinage totaled $1,044 million, down 10.7% from $1,168.5 million in FY 2020.

2021 Coin Shipments, Costs and Seigniorage
(coins and dollars in millions)

One-Cent Five-Cent Dime Quarter Half Dollar Mutilated & Other Total
Coins Shipments 7,613 1,736 3,066 2,274 12 14,701
Value of Shipments $76.1 $86.8 $306.6 $568.5 $6 $1,044.0
Gross Cost $159.7 $147.8 $134.6 $219.2 $1.4 $0.1 $662.8
Seigniorage ($83.6) ($61.0) $172.0 $349.3 $4.6 ($0.1) $381.2

 

After subtracting the year’s cost to produce the coins, which totaled $662.8 million, the U.S. Mint’s circulating profit or seigniorage totaled $381.20 million, representing a drop of $168.7 million, or 30.7%, from $549.9 million in FY 2020.

The Federal Government operates on a fiscal year that begins on October 1 and ends on September 30.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
40 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
c_q

I do not see the point in continuing to make 1-cent coins. They barely circulate, they spend 99.99% of their lifespan sitting in someone’s coin jar waiting to be dumped into a coinstar machine. Maybe instead of paying 2 cents for each new 1 cent coin manufactured, the treasury can just offer 2 cents for every 1-cent coin turned in to a coinstar machine for a set period of time – that should bring these coins out of the woodwork in droves, and the treasury will wind up with a huge supply and won’t need to ask the mint to… Read more »

Jeff Legan

I agree we should do away with the penny. The dollar bill also. I would prefer a dollar coin in its place. Wouldn’t it be nice to see circulating silver eagles? Slot machines would be more fun. How about we just turn the pennies in to any bank for the 2 cents. Coinstar could take part in this (get their 2 cents from the bank as well), but why should they be the one to run this program? Do you own stock in coinstar, or something? I have never used them. Don’t they charge a fee? You wouldn’t get a… Read more »

Asher Kobin

slot machines no longer use coins, it’s been all digital for 10+ years.

Mo L

There are definitely still slot machines that use coins. If youre in Vegas you can look them up, its only a couple places but theyre not extinct like phone booths. And I’m not even going to address the other stuff. You realize $63 million dollars in coins are thrown in the trash(sometimes vacuumed up, or myself, I throw pennies away often times. Not always but sometimes. Or they will otherwise go extinct around the country (thrown in the ocean, dropped in the middle of the forest, buried under somebodys grass)…so no, getting a few million pennies from coin jars is… Read more »

Kia99

Yes, no more pennies , no more nickels. We just need to convince congress and the zinc industry. It cost me more than a penny to buy a penny sized washer.

Clockwork Squirrel

Unfortunately we can’t get rid of nickels because the quarter isn’t a multiple of dimes. It would really complicate making change.

When Canada eliminated their 1¢ pieces they looked at killing the nickel too, but concluded it would only be practical if they withdrew their quarters and issued 20¢ coins instead.

Darn that need to stay compatible with Spanish pieces of eight!

LtCol Marshall Smith USMCR (Ret.)

You are welcome to send me all the coins you dont want.

Antonio

Time to follow Canada’s lead and discontinue the cent. The nickel’s composition should be changed to alter cost. Then again, the U.S. government isn’t particularly expert at cutting costs.

Rich

I don’t think the Govmint cares. Bring back Black Diamond! It’s all about bison and being buff…

buff.jpg
Major D

Antonio, I say yes to both of your points! discontinue the cent and alter the nickel’s composition to lower cost. How about taking the current cent planchet composition (97.5% zinc, 2.5% copper) and incorporate this into a new clad nickel being 8.33% nickel, same as the current dime and quarter composition? This would have the effect of lowering the metal value of the new “nickel” well under the face value. Although, without an actual one cent coin, does this render the current “five cent” label obsolete? Might need to change the coin to just say “Nickel” as the dime says… Read more »

Clockwork Squirrel

I have to agree with the Kaiser on this one. The basic units of our currency are dollars and cents, regardless of what coins are issued. E.g. none of the countries that eliminated their low-value coins (Canada, Australia, NZ, etc.) renamed the higher denominations. As far as the names themselves my, uh, 2¢ is they’re pretty much non-issues. Heck, ‘nickel’ isn’t even an official name – remember it came from 19th-century slang for any of the new nickel coins like white cents, trimes, etc. Plus ‘dime’ is a holdover from Jefferson’s original six-unit monetary system that included amounts expressed in… Read more »

Asher Kobin

The last time the US Government performed a major cut-cutting effort for coins was when they removed the silver content. That was a disaster.

erv

I like my coins to have a value that is about the same as the face value. With that being said, I am all for getting rid of the cent. For cash transactions the seller can always round down to the nearest nickel.

Uncle Sams Nephew

Keep the penny and nickel. I disagree with “rounding up or down”. The hope that it will equal out in the end is going to favor the “up” higher prices and fewer “down” lower prices. And it’s almost painless because a few pennies would not hurt too many people and their budgets. (except for Grandma Coinpurse seeking a shiny new nickel and four pennies in the express line when I’m in a hurry). But in the mega-data-banking-accounting business, (and within my wallet,) tracking the ups vs. downs in the counting function while considering the iffy decimal point of “plus-or-minus $0.0?”,… Read more »

Major D

Kaiser, I’m all on board for eliminating the cent. But how about going to a clad nickel? I suggest going with an 8.33% nickel component which is the same as with the current dime and quarter. However, instead of 91.67% copper go with the mix of the Shield cent (97.5% zinc and 2.5% copper). This would make the new “nickel” coin 8.33% nickel, 89.38% zinc and 2.29% copper. The weight lowers, but more significantly the metal value gets lowered well below 2 cents per coin. This approach keeps the dime “as is”.

Chris Terp

Coins last for years. If a penny costs 2.1 cents no matter as will be in circulation and used many times. As with anything the last two years you can probably blame it on COVID for price increase.

I am not a fan of rounding up or down. Corporations, banks and U.S. Government calculate to tenths of 1 cent. So as long as accountants do that you can expect having 1 cent, 5 cent and dime in circulation.

Chris Terp

Guess you forget those days Kaiser when young and/or in college and having to search your couch and car floor for change to purchase gas or a quick meal. In that case also, those coins matter. I save some pennies in a small container and when it gets full then start paying exact change at store making sure to use four pennies to get to 9. Plus many banks and grocery stores offer a coin counting machine. Although ones in grocery stores charge anywhere from 6%-10% for use 🙁 I have containers when I know they’re full get me anywhere… Read more »

Rich

That’s the Spirit!

Chris Terp

There are folks who refuse to use credit cards and prefer cash. I use both. So bills and coins are vital for them.

Also, vending machine, laundry mats business models is cash and especially use of coins. Although pennies not a factor for those two businesses.

Chris Terp

There are still tremendous amount of people under-banked in USA. COVID has forced many to use cards or some form of electronic payment lowering coin usage to sector specific Industries for the most part.

I am with you that some of those Industries going digital / electronic to help with maintenance. Suspect those sectors will either have a machine to take in currency and provide a cash card and/or accept credit debit cards.

There’s a population that will not get cards be it because of lack/bad credit, distrust of banking system, newly arrived aliens (legal or illegal) etc., etc.

LtCol Marshall Smith USMCR (Ret.)

We should just print dollar bills on toilet paper..

Rich

Good one, Sir!

toillet.jpg
Richard A

I think it’s time for legislation so the US Mint to start minting in 2023 a “TWO CENT” penny using the exact same design as the current “ONE CENT” coin and make the two interchangeable for three years and stop production of any 2023 “ONE CENT” pennies.
Furthermore, offer banks etc. $150 for every $100 of pennies returned after the “TWO CENT” version is introduced. Yes, there will be a 50% profit on returned coins but it offsets the cost of making the existing coin. We can live in a world where the lowest price is $0.02.

Big T

For those that think the US mint is “losing” money because they are spending 2 cents to make a one cent coin or paying more than 5 cents to make a nickel is not seeing the bigger picture. They also make 100 dollar bills that cost them about 15 cents (and only 5 cents for a one dollar bill – less security features) and 11 cents to make a quarter so clearly the situation is profitable overall. Yeah if all they made are cents and nickels then yes – that would be unsustainable, but the other currencies more than make… Read more »

Chris Terp

And distribution of currency is done by Treasury via Federal Reserve.

FViia

Just got taken by the local car wash I like. With quarters I could get it rinsed, soap/scrubbed, rinsed, and waxed for maybe ~$8 or less (each on a timer). Went in this week and he converted everything to card use, no quarters, and it cost me $14 and I hurried (min charge too). Swipe card and press stop when done. I knew something was up when there was a very large line for the automatic car wash, and hardly anyone for the self service bays. Might have been my last trip. Must have cost him a fortune for the… Read more »

Chris Terp

FViia,

It may have been costing owner small fortune repairing the coin operated mechanisms forcing him to switch to electronic payment systems too?

FViia

You can’t say it is the water (recycled), so maybe cost of chemicals, and also the higher gas and electric costs, and the recoup of machine retrofit. $14 to wash your car is excessive. Full service around here is $22, and they vacuum the inside, and clean the windows. Owning a pinball machine shows the mechanisms to be relatively cheap, so maybe that might not be the reason, but x??? quarters and in moisture environment takes a toll. There are significant front-end costs to opening an efficient car wash to get the water right. In some cases the water is… Read more »

Rich

Car Wash, Yeah!

carwash.jpg
Chris Terp

Excellent movie and soundtrack Kaiser 🙂

Rich

We’re all Kaisers now!

teen spirit.jpg
Chris Terp

Ah, ha ha ha – sorry about that Rich. Oopses.

Chris Terp

Labor costs have risen too FViia which may be more the culprit for price increase. Yes, chemicals, soaps, etc. have risen for the operation too in the inflationary times USA is in now. Yes, $22 is not a nice price for a car wash. I guess I am fortunate that I can’t have my Jeep Wrangler washed in a car wash because of the spare tire on back along with top brake light as part of the mount for that spare. Pinball machine probably not as complicated a mechanism than other coin operated machinery that’s exposed to the elements (outside).… Read more »

Chris Terp

Royal Mint in UK latest Music Legends silver coin is The Who. Pinball Wizard highlighted.

Screenshot_20220125-051638.png
Chris Terp

Royal Mint currently has Queen, David Bowie, Elton John and The Who coin ranges and came out in that order. I have Queen and Bowie coins Kaiser.

Guess when Disney runs low on quarterly performance rolls out a new Marvel hero for some quick bucks? 😉

Rich

Sir Kaiser, you are really on a roll today (LOL)! That has to be the best explanation of inflation ever.

baja.jpg
Rich

Sierra Hotel! Kaiser all the way!!

Uncle Sams Nephew

This has been an interesting and fun thread. I’m not able to cast forward a quadruple entendre, maybe just a bad rhyme this time. What’s all this talk and balk about the nickel and penny go-away. We’re the coin guys who squawk and hawk cents and that makes sense because they were found as bonus coins in sets, with hopes and bets that their value increases while the mint fleeces us with a free bonus if you are hooked on the mint’s phone-us or the predictable “no-way Jose” on the mint’s bad gateway any day for a nickel or penny,… Read more »

Rich

Uncle Sams Nephew for President!

sam2.jpg
Rob S

Got nuthin’ on the hip hop hippotamus, his rhymes are bottomless. (Conchords) 😉