Baldwin’s Hong Kong Coin Auction 51 Realizes $5.2+ Million

by Baldwin's on September 7, 2011 · 6 comments

As Baldwin’s (www.baldwin.co.uk) celebrated their 25th year of trading in the Orient bidders came out in force to ensure that this pinnacle auction was an outstanding success.

Hu Poo- Silver Pattern 1-Tael, Year 29

One of the highlights in the Hong Kong Coin Auction 51 was this Silver Pattern 1-Tael, Year 29 of Kuang Hsu, 1903 (Kann 927; L&M 1). It was estimated to bring between US$140,000-180,000. It realized $230,000.

The one day sale achieved an amazing, $5,256,675 (including buyer’s premium,) the highest total of any of Baldwin’s sales in the Orient and a fitting result for our 51st auction.

"It is magnificent to have achieved such a fantastic result from this sale and the perfect outcome to our 51st auction and our celebration of 25 years in the Orient," Edward Baldwin, Baldwin’s Chairman commented after the sale.

Held at The Holiday Inn Golden Mile in Kowloon, in conjunction with the Hong Kong International Coin Convention, the 1064 lot sale contained a plethora of Asian rarities. Some exceptional provenances and high grades were reflected in the prices achieved.

Of the 857 lots sold results across the board were strong with a shift in the value of items selling online in recent times becoming apparent, as big ticket items sold to bidders whose faith in live internet bidding has reached an all time high. 14.12% of lots offered sold online for US$526,307 (including buyer’s premium,) with a further 31% selling in the room with an internet buyer as the under bidder.

Lot 722, a Sun Yat-Sen Pattern Silver Dollar, Year 18, made in Italy sold online to a bidder in China for US$49,560.

The shift in interest from traditional to alternative investments has seen the banknote market flourish in recent months. The Chinese banknote section of the sale was proof positive that, like coins, well preserved, rare banknotes command high prices.

Highlights included lot 9, a Qing Dynasty, Ta Ching Pao Chao, 100,000-Cash note selling for US$35,400 with an estimate of US$30,000 — 35,000. This note was printed in the first year of issue of the largest denomination of the series, which made it a significantly rare piece. Lot 60, a specimen of the famous ‘5 beauties’ banknote, sold for US$5,900, against its estimate of US$2,000-2,500. The note features five women’s bust from the Han, Manchu, Mongolian, Xinjiang and Tibetan tribes of China, two on obverse and three on reverse. It is the only Chinese note with women as the central motif.

Lot 71, a Banque de l’Indo-Chine specimen dollar sold for US$17,700 in line with its pre-sale estimate of US$15,000-18,000. A beautiful and intricate banknote in design, and in pristine uncirculated condition, it is not difficult to see why such an eye-catching piece provoked such interest.

The China-Empire coins contained a number of outstanding rarities in high grade that were assured to be popular amongst the bidders.

Lot 298, a Hu Poo Silver Pattern 1-Tael was the star of the sale selling for US$271,400 against its estimate of US$140,000 — 180,000. This outstanding lot was one of a number of coins included in the sale that were sold previously through Baldwin’s as part of the Norman Jacobs Collection in 2008. If any more proof was needed regarding the strength of the Chinese market currently then the prices achieved for the ex Norman Jacobs lots included in the sale did just that.

Lot 351, a fine example of a Chekiang Province Silver Pattern 5-Cents, was originally purchased from Spink-Taisei in 1990 by Edward Baldwin for Norman Jacobs. He paid US$2,100 for the item that was sold in 2008 for US$40,000 and last week made an astonishing US$129,800.

Silver Pattern Dollar, Hsuan Tung Year 3 (1911)

Another Hong Kong Coin Auction 51 highlight was this Silver Pattern Dollar, Hsuan Tung Year 3 (1911), long whiskers dragon. (KM Pn40; Kann 223; L&M 28). It was estimated to bring between US$40,000-50,000. It realized $200,000.

Another incredible example of the surge in the market is lot 691, a Sun Yat-Sen Pattern Silver 50-Cents, Year 18. Made in Vienna this junk dollar was first purchased from the famous Kann collection in 1972 for US$90, it sold through the Hong Kong Coin Auction in 2008 for US$65,000, it opened last week at US$90,000, 1,000 times the amount it was bought for in 1972, and sold for an amazing US$188,800.

Lot 326, a long whisker dragon Silver Pattern Dollars from the Central mint at Tientsin, was the second of four examples included in the sale. Edward Baldwin, Chairman of Baldwin’s and A.H. Baldwin & Sons Oriental specialists commented prior to the sale that (including these four items) he had only ever encountered five examples of this pattern coin in his 40 years in the industry. It was therefore no surprise that this piece sold for an exceptional US$236,000 against an estimate of US$40,000-50,000.

Interesting and unusual lots dotted throughout the auction proved to be incredibly popular with buyers. The first of this kind was lot 241, an Eastern Han Bronze Mirror. Decorated with auspicious mythical beasts and ornate linked arcs on one side, the other is smooth and would have been polished to produce a reflection. This very special lot, estimated at US$500-600 sold for US$5,900.

Lot 343, a General Issues, Pattern Silver Mace came with an interesting and highly regarded provenance as it was sold as part of the 1954 Farouk Collection through Sotheby’s in Cairo. This legendary collection was famously catalogued by Fred Baldwin of A.H. Baldwin & Sons Ltd, with the assistance of Fred’s nephew Albert (father of current Chairman Edward Baldwin.) The cataloguing took place in Cairo, under military guard and in a very short period of time. The lot was estimated at US10,000-15,000 and, although bidding slowed temporarily at US$14,000 the lot finally achieved a staggering US$51,920.

Lot 950, a rare lot with wonderful historical resonance, sold in the room for US$165,200. The 1867 Victoria Silver Pattern 1-Tael was created as an attempt to bridge the gap between British and Chinese coin standards. The obverse of the coin depicts Queen Victoria with a key pattern design and the reverse Chinese characters.

High grade coins were plentiful in this sale and the common types in the highest grades really showed their worth with a number selling for well over pre-sale estimates. Lot 311, Lots 517 and 533, a Kwangtung Province Copper 10-Cash, and a Kwangtung Province Silver 10-Cents, were the two best examples selling for US$2,360 and US$33,040 respectively.

Lot 517 carried an estimate of US$100-150 and lot 533 was estimated at US$2,200-2,800. Lot 840, a Yuan Shih-Kai Gold Dollar (1916) a good quality piece, sold for double the bottom estimate of US20,000 for a spectacular US$44,840 and lot 1049, an 1886 Korean Yi-Hong Copper-gilt Pattern sold for US$14,160 against an estimate of US$2,000-2,500.

"The result of these many years of auctions and the tens of thousands of coins and banknotes sold can be measured by the increased level of numismatic activity at our auctions," added Baldwin.

"We are very proud of the arena that we have created, one that can only benefit the coin collector and add to the hobby. Many things have changed in the numismatic world over the last 25 years but our commitment to numismatics and to Asian numismatics in particular, has never faltered."

For a full copy of the prices relaised from this auction please visit www.baldwin.co.uk/auction-hkca51.

Additional Highlights from Baldwin’s Hong Kong Coin Auction 51

The following are other highlighs from Baldwin’s Hong Kong Coin Auction 51:

9 BANKNOTES. CHINA – EMPIRE, GENERAL ISSUES. Qing Dynasty, Ta Ching Pao Chao: 100,000-Cash, Xian Feng Year 7 (1857), serial no.12706 (P A8a). Usual spike holes at top and a small piece missing from top left corner, very fine and rare. This note is the first year of issue of the largest denomination of the series . Much rarer than the Hu Pu Kuan Piao 50-Taels

Estimate: US$30,000-35,000
Hammer: US$30,000

60 BANKNOTES. CHINA – REPUBLIC, GENERAL ISSUES. China & South Sea Bank Ltd: Colour Trial 10-Yuan, 1927, green instead of issued brown, punch-hole cancellation and red "SPECIMEN WATERLOW & SONS LTD" overprint (P A129 for type). Uncirculated and very scarce. the famous "5-beauties" note

Estimate: US$2,000-2,500
Hammer: US$5,000

71 BANKNOTES. CHINA – FOREIGN BANKS. Banque de l’Indo-Chine: Specimen Dollar (1-Piastre), 18 January 1902, Canton Shameen, serial no.0.00 000 (P S436 for issued note dated 15 January 1902). Small black smudge in right margin of the reverse, uncirculated and rare.

Estimate: US$15,000-18,000
Hammer: US$15,000

241 COINS. CHINA — ANCIENT. Eastern Han (25-220 AD): Bronze Mirror, with auspicious beasts, linked arcs and inscription including, diameter 152mm, thickness 9mm, 844g. Nice glossy black patina, well-preserved.

Estimate: US$500-600
Hammer: US$5,000

298 COINS. CHINA — EMPIRE, GENERAL ISSUES. Hu Poo: Silver Pattern 1-Tael, Year 29 of Kuang Hsu, 1903 (Kann 927; L&M 1). In NGC holder graded SP63, very rare. ex Dr Norman Jacobs collection, Hong Kong Coin Auction, Baldwin – Ma Tak Wo, August 2008, lot 44

Estimate: US$140,000-180,000
Hammer: US$230,000

311 COINS. CHINA — EMPIRE, GENERAL ISSUES. Central Mint at Tientsin: Silver Pattern Dollar, CD1907 (KM K212; Kann 212; L&M 20). Lightly toned, uncirculated.

Estimate: US$8,000-10,000
Hammer: US$50,000

326 COINS. CHINA — EMPIRE, GENERAL ISSUES. Central Mint at Tientsin: Silver Pattern Dollar, Hsuan Tung Year 3 (1911), long whisker dragon (KM Pn40; Kann 223; L&M 28). In NGC holder graded MS63, rare.

Estimate: US$40,000-50,000
Hammer: US$200,000

343 COINS. CHINA — EMPIRE, GENERAL ISSUES. General Issues: Pattern Silver Mace, Kwan Ping, ND (c.1858), Obv denomination within wreath of tea branches, Rev the Ying-yang symbol at centre, two dragons chasing each other in the outer circle, reeded edge, 20mm, 3.625g (Kann 926II; L&M 598). Rim nick on the reverse, otherwise prooflike mint state, in PCGS holder graded SP62 and exceedingly rare. ex Farouk collection, Sotheby’s, Cairo (Egypt), 24 February — 3 March 1954 Kann thought these pieces were struck in England by the Royal Mint, London, but this cannot yet be confirmed.

Estimate: US$10,000-15,000
Hammer: US$44,000

351 COINS. CHINA — PROVINCIAL ISSUES. Chekiang Province: Silver Pattern 5-Cents, ND (1902), by Heaton Mint, Birmingham, England (Kann 123I; L&M 280; J O Sweeney The Birmingham Mint CN2p). In NGC holder graded SP67, rare. ex Dr Norman Jacobs collection, Hong Kong Coin Auction, Baldwin – Ma Tak Wo, August 2008, lot 74 ex Spink-Taisei Singapore Auction 8, 22 February 1990, lot 695B

Estimate: US$70,000-80,000
Hammer: US$110,000

429 COINS. CHINA — PROVINCIAL ISSUES. Hupeh Province: Silver Tael, Year 30 (1904), small central characters (KM Y128.2; L&M 180). In PCGS holder graded MS64.

Estimate: US$20,000-25,000
Hammer: US$60,000

517 COINS. CHINA — PROVINCIAL ISSUES. Kwangtung Province: Copper 10-Cash, ND (1900-1906) (CCC 6). Nearly uncirculated with much lustre.

Estimate: US$100-150
Hammer: US$2,000

533 COINS. CHINA — PROVINCIAL ISSUES. Kwangtung Province: Silver 20-Cents, ND (1891) (KM Y201; Kann 28; L&M 135). In NGC holder graded SP66.

Estimate: US$2,200-2,800
Hammer: US$28,000

558 COINS. CHINA — PROVINCIAL ISSUES. Shensi Province: Silver Pattern 20-Cents, ND (1898) (Kann 157; L&M 375; J O Sweeney The Birmingham Mint CN35p). In NGC holder graded SP67, very rare. ex Dr Norman Jacobs collection, Hong Kong Coin Auction, Baldwin – Ma Tak Wo, August 2008, lot 380 ex NASCA Wayte Raymond "Mintmaster" Auction, December 1977, lot 944

Estimate: US$45,000-55,000
Hammer: US$90,000

650 COINS. CHINA — PROVINCIAL ISSUES. Kwangtung Province: Brass struck Pattern 10-Cash, machine made, (Guang Xu Zhong Bao), Rev (Guangdong Mint) in Manchu (KM Pn3; CCC 778). Brilliant uncirculated, very rare.

Estimate: US$10,000-15,000
Hammer: US$22,000

691 COINS. CHINA — GENERAL ISSUES. Sun Yat-Sen: Pattern Silver 50-Cents, Year 18 (1929), made in Vienna (Austria), Obv bust left, Rev sailing junk (KM Pn96; Kann 617I; L&M 98). In NGC holder graded MS62, extremely rare. only two pieces retained by the mint, the rest were melted ex Kann collection, March 1972, lot 2061 ex Dr Norman Jacobs collection, Hong Kong Coin Auction, Baldwin – Ma Tak Wo, August 2008, lot 568

Estimate: US$100,000-120,000
Hammer: US$160,000

722 COINS. CHINA — GENERAL ISSUES. Sun Yat-Sen: Pattern Silver Dollar, Year 18 (1929), made in Italy, Obv bust left Rev sailing junk (KM Pn97; Kann 614; L&M 92). In PCGS holder graded SP63.

Estimate: US$6,000-8,000
Hammer: US$42,000

840 COINS. CHINA — GENERAL ISSUES. Yuan Shih-Kai: Gold Dollar, ND (1916), on the installation of Yuan Shih-Kai as the Emperor Hung Hsien, Obv ¾-facing bust, Rev dragon (KM Pn44; Kann 1560; L&M 1114). In NGC holder graded MS62.

Estimate: US$20,000-25,000
Hammer: US$38,000

876 COINS. CHINA — Fantasy: Gold "25-Taels", 1869, Obv the Tantric God Mahakala seated on lotus flower, two dragons in border, Rev two upright dragons facing beneath fireball, English and Chinese legends around, (Hsin Wei Tung Chi) in centre, "EMPIRE OF CHINA" above, 50mm, 90.85g. Uncirculated.

Estimate: US$15,000-20,000
Hammer: US$34,000

950 COINS – CHINA – HONG KONG. Victoria: Silver Pattern 1-Tael, 1867, Obv diademed bust of Queen Victoria left, key pattern border dividing legend "VICTORIA" and "QUEEN", Rev dot at centre with "TRIAL" above, surrounded and "986" below, all within a beaded circle; in the outer circle, "ONE TAEL . HONG-KONG" and "1867" separated by two five-pointed stars, reeded edge (Prid 314; KM Y Pn122). In NGC holder graded PF62, very rare.

Estimate: US$150,000-200,000
Hammer: US$140,000

About Baldwin’s

Established in 1872 A. H. Baldwin & Sons Ltd (www.baldwin.co.uk) has over 100 years experience in servicing the numismatic industry. Although founded much earlier, the name A.H. Baldwin & Sons didn’t become synonymous with the London numismatic scene until 1901 when Albert Henry set up his first London based premises on Duncannon Street with his eldest son Percy, joined later by his two other sons Fred (legendary cataloguer of King Farouk of Egypt’s coin collection) and Roy.

Baldwin’s auction department was established in 1993 and has grown to hold between ten and twelve sales annually in London, New York, Hong Kong and Dubai and specialize in all areas of Numismatics.

{ 6 comments… read them below or add one }

brandi October 22, 2011 at 11:25 pm

My name is Brandi and i have a question about the 29th year of Kuang Hsu Hu Poo coin. I have one of the coins and I am wondering if it is real or fake. It looks exactly like the one in the picture on your website and it is silver. Do you think you can point me in the right direction to find out more about these coins I have? I also have a 34th year coin and some others.

Joe Cero Jr January 28, 2012 at 3:56 pm

I seem to have a coin ” 29th year of Kuang HSU”. I have a total of 7 silver TAEL
coins. I would like to have someone review them and help me sell them.

Franklin S. Kelly June 4, 2012 at 4:52 pm

Watch our for the old Hong Kong “silver” coins. Many are neither old nor silver. I bought one on e-Bay and it is a fake. I’m hoping to get my money returned.

mkg February 13, 2013 at 6:06 am

I have one 10 Cash pattern coin from madres presidency and it looks like gold coin. But I am not sure if it is gold or any other metal? Kindly let me know the origin of the said coin. Thanking you.

donald potvin March 24, 2013 at 4:45 pm

My name is donaldand I have a question about the 34th year of Guangxu piece pei yang. I have one coin and I wonder if it is true or false. It looks just like the picture on your website and it is silver. Do you think you can point me in the right direction for more information

Ibrahim August 4, 2014 at 7:32 pm

I have a question, I have one coin china republic general issue 1916. it looks like the picture on the website, i hope its genuene and can sell for good price.

Leave a Comment